1890
Robert C.Lee*, Sept. 1894-Sept. 1896
[1895-Methodist Community Church built on Sequim Avenue & Fir Street]
L.M. Haworth (Supply Pastor)*, Dec. 1896-Sept. 1898
[1897-first Conference appointment]
H.D.Wadsworth*, Sept. 1898-Jan. 1899
S.G.Jones*, March 1899-Sept. 1899
1900
W. M.Welch*, Sept. 1899-Sept. 1901
T.S.Dyer*, Sept. 1901-Sept. 1902
A.H.Marsh*, Sept. 1902-Sept. 1903
George F. Graham*, Jan. 1904-Jan. 1905
T.S. Winey (Supply Pastor), Jan. 1905-May 1905
G.A. Voris (Supply Pastor), May 1905-Sept. 1905
A.J. McNemee, Sept. 1905-Sept. 1907
A. Davis (Supply Pastor), Sept. 1907-June 1910
1910
C.N. Goulder (Supply Pastor), June 1910-Jan. 1911
F.R.Mathews (Supply Pastor), Jan. 1911-Sept. 1911
A.B.Simpson (Supply Pastor), Sept. 1911-Sept. 1913
R.C.Johnson*, 1913
E.R. Colwell*, 1914
Furman F. Frisbie, Sept. 1915-Sept. 1916
C.W. McLaughlin (Supply Pastor), Sept. 1916-Sept. 1917
W. H. W.Rees, Jr., Sept. 1917
Robert C.Hartley, April 1918-Sept. 1920
1920
W.L. Airheart, Sept.- Nov. 1920
Ernest J. Bates, Nov. 1920-Sept. 1924
T.W. Bundy, Sept. 1924-Sept. 1925
J.M. Amundson (Supply Pastor), Sept. 1925-Sept. 1928
D.Stanley McGuire (Supply Pastor) Sept. 1928-June 1930
1930
[1929-Trinity Methodist-Episcopal Church rebuilt on the same site]
Benjamin H. Hart, June 1930-June 1935
Virgil A.Kraft, June 1935-June 1937
Decatur N. Lacy, June 1937-June 1938
William G.R. Dann, June 1938-June 1945
1940
Margaret Davis (Supply Pastor), June 1945-June 1946
1950
R. Clinton McGaffee, June 1946-June 1952
Fletcher Forster, Nov. 1952-June 1957
J. Dean Stout, June 1957-June 1959
Robert C. Ward, June 1959-June 1963
1960
Vincent S. Hart, Jr., June 1963-June 1966
Jerry F. Smith, June 1966-June 1970
1970
Bruce B. Groseclose, June 1970-June 1973
Elmer L. Bigham, June 1973-June 1982
1980
Earl L. Dean, June 1982-June 1988
Roger W. Barr, June 1988-June 1997
1990
[1991-New church (Trinity United Methodist) built on Blake Avenue; Sequim Avenue church building sold to Boys & Girls Club]
Earl H. Rice June 1997-June 2001
2000
Gisela E.Taber June 2001-June 2007
William Gordon June 2007-June 2011
2010
William G. Green June 2011-June 2020
2020
Bradley Beeman July 2020-August 2021
Joey Olson, September 2021-June 2022 Desi Larson, July 2022-
Sources: Church records, supplemented by information published in Methodism in the Northwest, by Erle Howell, Parthenon Press, 1966, p. 435.
* Appointment shared with Dungeness church.
A Supply Pastor is a layperson appointed by the District Superintendent to serve as pastor of a local church, usually to fill a short-term/temporary need for pastoral leadership.